Phone Records, Privacy and Congress
Qwest rebuked the call for records, according to the report, and pressed the NSA for a court order. Why? There's this pesky thing called the 1986 Electronic Communications Privacy Act (passed by a Republican Senate and President). Section 2702(a)(3) specifically prohibits phone companies from doing what they did (emphasis added):
[A] provider of remote computing service or electronic communication service to the public shall not knowingly divulge a record or other information pertaining to a subscriber to or customer of such service (not including the contents of communications covered by paragraph (1) or (2)) to any governmental entity.That law is the basis for a class action suit filed against Verizon in New Jersey on Friday.
The law might have originated with a review of the history of government intrusion into private lives: "From the Red Scare in the 1920s to illegal wiretaps during the Nixon era, Americans have struggled to find the right balance between individual rights and collective security."
To date, history has not found any of these programs to be, erh, appropriate.
Smith v Maryland
Congress acted long after a 1979 US Supreme Court decision in Smith v Maryland. In that case, police sought telephone records to determine a claim that a victim of a crime was being phoned by the suspect of the crime. The police used a "pen register" to capture outbound calls placed by the suspect. The Court ruled that this "search" did not require a warrant.
The only parallel between Smith v Maryland and the current NSA action is that law enforcement got phone numbers. Note that the phone company did not turn over the records in the Maryland case. Instead, police attached a device on telephone company equipment to capture the numbers dialed.
Moreover, the Maryland case was an active criminal investigation of a discrete nature (one person's phone, limited time - not years). It was not a fishing expedition, which is the only way you can characterize compiling data on millions of American citizens.
Even J. Edgar didn't dream of capturing this volume of data.
Hayden Hearing Impact
News coverage of the NSA action threatens to overshadow confirmation hearings for General Michael V. Hayden. President Bush has nominated Hayden to be the next chief of the CIA. However, Hayden is the architect of the controversial NSA wiretapping program, favored by Vice President Cheney, which the New York Times broke in late 2005:
[Hayden] aw the opportunity to use the N.S.A.'s enormous technological capabilities by loosening restrictions on the agency's operations inside the United States.
For his part, Mr. Cheney helped justify the program with an expansive theory of presidential power, which he explained to traveling reporters a few days after The Times first reported on the program in December.
Technorati Profile
Technorati tags:
NSA,
Politics
gada.be tags:
NSA,
Politics
Comments
Liberals are uniformly depressed and frightened over this. See my post regarding liberal blogs on this matter.
Electronic Elephants Endanger Our Freedom, Our Families & Our Future
There is compelling evidence classified electronic and sonic weapons technology developed by the U.S. Government is now in the hands of hate groups and organized crime.
These covert weapons are being used secretly and silently to harass loyal Americans, strangle their businesses and gain control of their assets.
So long as this technology remains classified, responsible government agencies cannot protect American citizens, families and businesses from these threats.
See www.ElectronicElephants.com [1] for further details and lists of reputable resources and links describing the electronic weaponry threat and asking Congress to investigate and stop it.
How Did This Happen? - The U.S. Government does not build bombers or battleships. It contracts with outside private companies to procure products and programs. Most military research and development remains classified unless there are compelling reasons to make it public.
Some of this electronic harassment technology has leaked from the hands of these private contractors. The U.S. Government does not want to admit the threat exists or that they have lost control of the technology.
Why Is It So Hard To Detect? - Most bio-affective sonic and electro magnetic frequencies lie in the extremely low frequency range of 5 to 300 cycles per second which mimic and parallel the electronic functioning of the human nervous system.
Since there are relatively few legitimate commercial uses for these extremely low frequency transmissions, test equipment to detect and prove their use is not currently available for a reasonable price.
What Are The Effects Of These Weapons? - It is well known and well documented that extremely low frequency sonic and electromagnetic frequencies can disorient and disrupt human functioning, cause memory loss and confusion. Some frequencies can induce heart attack or stroke. Recent publicity about active denial technologies indicate they can cause pain, serious injury and death.
This classified, covert technology is now in the hands of organized crime and hate groups. The implications and impact on our freedom and future are horrifying.
Contact your congressmen and ask them to make this technology public and provide law enforcement agencies with the technology and training they need to protect us from these dangers.
www.ElectronicElephants.com